“Terror belli… decus pacis.” These Latin words, meaning “Terror in war… ornament in peace,” were inscribed on the baton of every French Marshal. In France, the title of Marshal, or Maréchal, dates back to at least the 13th century, representing the pinnacle of military authority. This prestigious rank was abolished during the French Revolution due to its conflict with the era’s egalitarian ideals. However, in 1804, Napoleon Bonaparte restored the title as he established a new empire. This article explores the lives and careers of some of Napoleon’s most notable Marshals, ranked based on their achievements and with insights from Lieutenant Colonel Rémy Porte, a former chief historian of the French Army.
Gouvion Saint-Cyr was a brilliant student who left a challenging childhood to pursue art. A fervent supporter of the French Revolution, he volunteered for military service, quickly rising to the rank of captain due to his intelligence and republican ideals. His talent for mapping enemy positions caught the attention of General Custine, leading to a staff position. Despite lacking formal military training, Saint-Cyr’s strategic acumen propelled him from volunteer to general of division in just two years. However, his analytical nature made him respected but not beloved.
After serving with the Army of the Rhine, Saint-Cyr was sent to Italy, where he skillfully managed a retreat at the Battle of Novi. He later achieved a significant victory against the Austrians at Biberach. Despite his military prowess, his political views and disputes with commanders like General Moreau hindered his career. Saint-Cyr opposed Napoleon’s rise to power and was sidelined for several years.
In 1808, he commanded a corps in Spain but was relieved after failing to capture Gerona. His military abilities were undeniable, and he was recalled for the 1812 Russian campaign, where he turned a likely defeat at Polotsk into a victory, earning his Marshal’s baton. Despite being wounded and contracting typhus, he returned to lead the defense of Dresden in 1813, earning Napoleon’s respect. However, he was cut off after the defeat at Leipzig and later retired, disillusioned by politics.
Nicolas Oudinot joined the army at 17 but returned home to help with the family business. He volunteered for the National Guard during the Revolution and quickly rose through the ranks, known for his bravery and frequent injuries. Promoted to General of Division in 1799, he excelled as General Masséna’s chief of staff in Switzerland and later led a successful cavalry charge in Italy.
In 1805, Napoleon gave Oudinot command of an elite Grenadier Division. Despite a thigh wound, he led his troops at the Battle of Austerlitz. His division captured a British sloop at the siege of Danzig and played a crucial role at Friedland. In 1809, after being wounded at Aspern, he succeeded Marshal Lannes and led the Second Corps to victory at Wagram, earning his Marshal’s baton and the title Duke of Reggio.
During the 1812 Russian campaign, Oudinot was wounded at Polotsk but returned to lead his corps during the retreat from Moscow. He was shot again at the Berezina River but continued to serve in Germany in 1813. Despite a defeat at Grossbeeren, he remained a loyal and courageous commander. Oudinot refused to serve Napoleon during the Hundred Days, maintaining his loyalty to the monarchy. Known for his numerous battle wounds, he lived to 80, serving as Governor of Les Invalides.
Claude Victor-Perrin was an experienced soldier by the Revolution, quickly rising to brigadier general after a successful assault at Toulon alongside Napoleon. Despite his disapproval of Napoleon’s political ambitions, he served under him in Italy and distinguished himself at Marengo.
Victor’s career stalled due to his political views, but he became chief of staff for Marshal Lannes in 1806 and later commanded the Tenth Corps. Captured by a Prussian patrol, he was exchanged for General von Blücher. In 1807, he led the First Corps at Friedland, earning his Marshal’s baton and the title Duke of Belluno.
In Spain, Victor achieved victories at Medellín and nearly succeeded at Talavera. However, his siege of Cadiz was unsuccessful. During the Russian campaign, his Ninth Corps covered the retreat from Moscow, notably at the Berezina River. In 1813, he fought at Dresden and Leipzig, but was relieved of command in 1814 after a dispute with Napoleon. He later served the Bourbon monarchy, voting for Marshal Ney’s execution, a decision he regretted.
Joachim Murat, the son of an innkeeper, left a religious path to join the cavalry. His career took off when he helped Napoleon suppress a Parisian mob in 1795. As Napoleon’s aide-de-camp, Murat became known for his bold cavalry leadership and flamboyant style.
In Egypt, he captured the Ottoman commander at Aboukir despite being wounded. Back in France, he played a key role in Napoleon’s coup. Murat married Napoleon’s sister Caroline and commanded the cavalry reserve at Marengo. As a Marshal, he led successful campaigns in 1805 and 1806, including a daring bluff at a bridge during the Ulm campaign.
Despite Napoleon’s criticisms, Murat’s battlefield leadership was exceptional, as seen at Austerlitz and Jena. In 1808, he was sent to Spain, where his harsh response to the Madrid uprising marked his tenure. Although he hoped to become King of Spain, that title went to Joseph Bonaparte, leaving Murat with mixed feelings about his role in the empire.
Engage in a role-playing debate where you assume the roles of Napoleon’s Marshals: Saint-Cyr, Oudinot, Victor, and Murat. Research their military strategies, political views, and personal traits. Debate key decisions made during their careers, such as their actions in the Russian campaign or their stance during the Hundred Days. This will help you understand their motivations and the impact of their decisions on Napoleon’s empire.
Work in groups to analyze historical maps of key battles involving the Marshals, such as the Battle of Polotsk or the Siege of Cadiz. Identify the strategic movements made by each Marshal and discuss how their decisions influenced the outcomes. Present your findings to the class, highlighting the strategic acumen of each Marshal and how it contributed to their legacy.
Choose one Marshal and conduct in-depth research on their life and career. Prepare a presentation that covers their early life, rise to power, key military achievements, and political challenges. Focus on how their personal beliefs and relationships with Napoleon influenced their actions. This activity will deepen your understanding of the complex personalities behind these historical figures.
Write a fictional diary entry from the perspective of one of the Marshals during a pivotal moment in their career, such as the retreat from Moscow or the defense of Dresden. Use historical facts to guide your narrative, but explore the emotional and psychological aspects of their experiences. This exercise will help you empathize with the challenges faced by these leaders.
Participate in a class discussion about the long-term impact of Napoleon’s Marshals on military history and their legacy in modern France. Consider how their careers influenced military tactics, leadership styles, and the political landscape of Europe. Reflect on the phrase “Terror in war… ornament in peace” and how it applies to the lives of these Marshals.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript, with any potentially sensitive or inappropriate content removed or modified for clarity:
—
“Terror belli… decus pacis.” Terror in war… ornament in peace… The words inscribed on every French Marshal’s baton. In France, the title of Marshal, or Maréchal, goes back at least to the 13th century. It represents the highest possible position of military authority – authority symbolized by a marshal’s baton. The title was abolished during the French Revolution, as incompatible with the egalitarian spirit of the age. But in 1804, Napoleon founded a new empire and restored the ancient rank. This is Epic History TV’s guide to Napoleon’s Marshals. All 26 have been ranked according to our own evaluation of their achievements as Marshals, with expert guidance from Lieutenant Colonel Rémy Porte, former chief historian of the French Army.
So far, we’ve met Marshals Pérignon, Brune, Sérurier, Kellermann, Grouchy, Moncey, Poniatowski, Jourdan, Bernadotte, Augereau, and Lefebvre.
**13. Marshal Saint-Cyr**
Gouvion Saint-Cyr was a gifted student who ran away from a difficult childhood to become an artist. A passionate republican, he embraced the French Revolution and later volunteered for military service. Though proud and aloof by nature, his republican politics and sharp intellect ensured he was elected captain of his company. His skill at drawing enemy positions got him noticed by General Custine, who gave him a job on his staff. During these turbulent early years of the Revolution, Custine was one of several generals punished for his defeats. Saint-Cyr’s instinctive grasp of warfare, brilliant planning, and tactics won him promotion from volunteer to general of division in two years – an even more remarkable achievement as he had no formal military training. However, his cold, analytical approach meant that he was always a respected leader rather than a beloved one.
After five years’ service with the Army of the Rhine, he was sent to Italy. At the disastrous Battle of Novi, he commanded the French right wing but skillfully extricated his troops from the debacle. The next year he was back on the Rhine and won a brilliant victory over the Austrians at Biberach. However, a bitter dispute with his commander, General Moreau, encouraged rumors that Saint-Cyr was difficult to work with. Saint-Cyr believed soldiers should not meddle in politics and did not support Napoleon’s seizure of power in 1799, nor did he show much enthusiasm for Napoleon’s decision to crown himself Emperor five years later. His political views cost him dearly: Saint-Cyr was sidelined for several years while less able generals were made Marshals.
In 1805, he commanded French forces in central Italy, but when he was made subordinate to Marshal Masséna, a man he personally detested, he returned to Paris, even when Napoleon threatened to have him shot for desertion. In 1808, Saint-Cyr was given command of a corps for the invasion of Spain. However, his failure to take Gerona meant he was relieved of command. Leaving in frustration before his replacement Marshal Augereau had arrived, he was nearly court-martialed again for desertion. Saint-Cyr’s military talent, however, was not in doubt. In 1812, he was recalled for the Russia campaign, with command of the Sixth Bavarian Corps. His role was to support Marshal Oudinot in guarding the northern flank of the French salient. When Wittgenstein’s Russians attacked at Polotsk, Oudinot was wounded, and Saint-Cyr took over command, turning probable defeat into a brilliant victory. For this achievement, Napoleon awarded Saint-Cyr his Marshal’s baton. But two months later, at the Second Battle of Polotsk, Saint-Cyr was attacked by a larger Russian army, seriously wounded in the foot, and forced to pull back. His injury meant he missed the worst horrors of the Russian retreat, but he contracted typhus early in 1813 and was sick for many months.
Saint-Cyr returned to the Grande Armée in August, taking command of the Fourteenth Corps and the defense of Dresden. Incredibly, this was the first and only time that he worked directly alongside the Emperor, and both soon learned new respect for each other’s abilities. Saint-Cyr’s skilled defense of Dresden set the stage for Napoleon’s great victory there later that month. But Saint-Cyr was incredulous when Napoleon later ordered him to remain in Dresden while other forces concentrated for the decisive Battle of Leipzig, 60 miles to the west. Napoleon’s defeat at Leipzig meant that Saint-Cyr and other garrisons in the east were cut off and had to surrender that autumn. Saint-Cyr took no part in the Hundred Days, determined to keep out of France’s political disputes. Under the restored monarchy, he served as Minister of War and tried but failed to save Marshal Ney from the death penalty. He also struggled to enact military reforms in the face of royalist opposition, eventually resigning in disappointment and retiring to his country estate. Marshal Saint-Cyr remains one of the great ‘what-ifs’ of the Napoleonic Wars – an extremely able commander sidelined for his politics, who might well have proved one of Napoleon’s very best Marshals.
**12. Marshal Oudinot**
Nicolas Oudinot ran away to join the army at 17, but his father brought him home three years later to help run the family business. When the Revolution began, he volunteered for the National Guard and was promoted to Major. In the wars that followed, he served with the Army of the Rhine, always in the thick of the fighting, rapidly promoted and frequently wounded – a habit for which he became celebrated. In 1799, he was promoted to General of Division and sent to Switzerland to serve as General Masséna’s new chief of staff, a role he performed exceptionally well. Serving with General Brune in Italy, he led a cavalry charge against an Austrian battery at the Battle of Monzembano, sabering gunners and capturing one cannon himself, a feat for which Napoleon awarded him a sword of honor.
In 1805, the newly-crowned Emperor Napoleon gave Oudinot command of an elite Grenadier Division, formed from the tallest, strongest soldiers in the army. In December that year, at the Battle of Austerlitz, Oudinot insisted on leading the division in person, despite having been shot in the thigh two weeks earlier. His grenadiers were kept in reserve for most of the battle but saw heavy fighting in the latter stages, as Napoleon completed the destruction of the Allied left wing. At the siege of Danzig in 1807, General Oudinot’s division had the unusual distinction of capturing an enemy warship – a British sloop that had run aground trying to resupply the city. A month later at Friedland, Oudinot and his grenadiers were under Marshal Lannes’ command and played a crucial role holding up the Russian army until Napoleon arrived to deal a decisive blow.
During the 1809 war with Austria, Oudinot was wounded once more at the Battle of Aspern. When Marshal Lannes died of his wounds, Napoleon chose Oudinot to succeed him as commander of the Second Corps. He led his new corps with such success at Wagram six weeks later that Napoleon attributed victory to both Masséna and Oudinot. A week later, he became one of three new Marshals: ‘one for France, one for the army, one for friendship’. Oudinot was the army’s choice – fearless and much loved, a man whose courage inspired all around him. He later received an additional reward – the title Duke of Reggio.
In 1812, Marshal Oudinot led the Second Corps into Russia but was wounded again at Polotsk and handed over command to General Saint-Cyr. Ten weeks later he was back with his corps, marching south to join Napoleon’s army on its retreat from Moscow. Oudinot’s men were shocked when they saw their old comrades from the main column; they looked more like fugitives than soldiers of the Grande Armée. Since Oudinot’s Second Corps was in better shape than most, it formed the vanguard for the desperate crossing of the Berezina River. But the next day, in bitter fighting to hold the bridgehead against the Russians, Oudinot was shot from his saddle. He was carried back to a cottage with a serious gunshot wound, but then he and his party became surrounded by Cossacks. Oudinot asked for his pistols and, from his bed, aiming through an opening opposite, began firing at the Cossacks. They were rescued by friendly troops just in time.
Oudinot was back with the Grande Armée in Germany in 1813. In August, Napoleon ordered him to lead an advance on Berlin, but he was defeated by Bernadotte’s Army of the North at Grossbeeren. He then retreated in the wrong direction, causing Napoleon to remark, “It’s truly difficult to have less brains than the Duke of Reggio.” In Oudinot’s defense, he’d probably been given an impossible task – insufficient men to take on a strong opponent, bad weather, terrible roads, and he himself unwell – possibly not yet recovered from his ordeal in Russia. Napoleon put Oudinot back where he was most effective, leading troops in combat under his close supervision. At Leipzig, he commanded two divisions of the Young Guard, engaged in heavy fighting on the southern front for two days.
Oudinot continued to serve the Emperor courageously and loyally as a corps commander in the final campaign of 1814 – but in April, he was one of several Marshals to confront Napoleon with the reality of his position and force his abdication. When Napoleon returned from exile in 1815, Oudinot refused to break his new oath to the monarchy but declared neutrality, telling Napoleon, “Since I shall not serve you, Sire, I shall serve no one.” He continued to hold senior commands under the Bourbons. By one estimate, Oudinot was wounded 36 times in his military career, more than any other Marshal. Here are just 20 that we found details for. A fellow officer, who bathed with him at a spa after the war, saw the scars on his body and observed, “He was little more than a colander.” Ironically, Oudinot was also one of the longest-lived Marshals, dying aged 80 while serving as Governor of Les Invalides.
**11. Marshal Victor**
Claude Victor-Perrin was an experienced soldier by the time of the French Revolution, a sergeant with eight years’ service in the Grenoble Artillery Regiment. The Revolutionary Wars brought the opportunity for rapid promotion, and by 1793 he was commanding an infantry battalion at the Siege of Toulon. He led a daring night assault on British defenses alongside the army’s artillery chief, a young Major Bonaparte. Both men were wounded, but the attack was a success, and both were quickly promoted to brigadier general. Victor served under General Bonaparte in Italy and turned out to be a brilliant brigade commander. In 1800, he distinguished himself at the Battle of Marengo, where his command of the left wing won particular praise from Napoleon.
But Victor did not hide his disapproval of Napoleon’s quest for political power, and as a result, received relatively minor roles under the new regime. In 1802 he was earmarked to lead an expedition to recover the French territory of Louisiana, but it was called off when Napoleon decided instead to sell Louisiana to the United States. Victor and Marshal Lannes were close friends from their days serving together in Italy. In 1806, Lannes persuaded Napoleon to let him have Victor as his new chief of staff for the Fifth Corps. Napoleon agreed, and in October, Victor served as Lannes’ deputy at the Battle of Jena. Napoleon’s earlier misgivings about Victor were now forgotten, and that winter he was given command of the newly-formed Tenth Corps. But within weeks he was captured by a Prussian patrol and had to be exchanged for a captured Prussian officer… General von Blücher.
His big break came in 1807, stepping in for the wounded Marshal Bernadotte to command the First Corps at Friedland, where he successfully led a major attack as the Emperor looked on. Promotion to Marshal and the title Duke of Belluno swiftly followed. In 1808, Marshal Victor and the First Corps took part in the invasion of Spain, where he’d be posted for the next three years. Victor’s record in Spain was better than most, but like others, he seemed more interested in personal glory and rewards than in cooperating with fellow commanders. In 1809 at Medellín, he inflicted a crushing defeat on General Cuesta’s Spanish army. Four months later, his bold night attack on the British at Talavera came tantalizingly close to success. He was furious the next day when King Joseph and Marshal Jourdan refused to support fresh attacks and instead ordered a cautious withdrawal.
The next year Victor besieged the Spanish port of Cadiz. It proved a lengthy, futile operation, devoid of glory, and saw his troops defeated by an allied sortie at the Battle of Barrosa. In 1812, Victor was recalled from Spain for the invasion of Russia. His Ninth Corps was held in reserve for most of the campaign, though his troops were kept busy defending depots and convoys from Cossack raids. That autumn, his corps attempted to cover the main army’s retreat from Moscow. The greatest crisis of the retreat came at the Berezina River. As the remnants of the Grande Armée began crossing over two improvised bridges, Victor’s Ninth Corps was ordered to form the rearguard. Though heavily outnumbered, Victor skillfully handled his French and German troops, holding the Russians at bay as the army made its escape. He then marched his surviving troops over the bridges in good order – a courageous performance in desperate circumstances.
In Germany in 1813, Victor commanded the Second Corps and led the attack in Napoleon’s last great victory at Dresden. His corps was in heavy fighting again at Leipzig two months later. Victor continued to serve at the Emperor’s side in the defense of France in 1814. By now, like many comrades, he must have been close to physical and psychological exhaustion. Regardless, during the Battle of Montereau, Napoleon let fly at him for failing to get his troops into position and blamed him for the Allies’ escape. Victor was relieved of command. But angry and humiliated at what he considered his unfair dismissal, he told the Emperor: “Marshal Victor has not forgotten his old trade. I will shoulder a musket and take my place in the Guard.” Moved by this response, Napoleon relented and gave Victor command of a corps of Young Guard. Two weeks later, he was badly wounded at the Battle of Craonne and took no further part in the war.
A month later Napoleon abdicated, and Victor switched his loyalty to the Bourbon monarchy with surprising zeal. He led an investigation into former comrades who’d supported Napoleon during the Hundred Days and was one of only two active Marshals to vote for the death penalty for Marshal Ney – a decision he later claimed to regret. Victor later served as Minister of War but retired from public life in 1830, following the overthrow of the Bourbon monarchy.
**10. Marshal Murat**
Joachim Murat, the son of an innkeeper, was destined for a career in the church but dropped out of college and joined a cavalry regiment instead. To his immense frustration, he saw little action in the early years of the Revolutionary Wars, being stuck with staff and training roles. But in 1795, while stationed in Paris with the 21st Chasseurs, fate intervened. A young general, Napoleon Bonaparte, had been put in charge of the defense of the National Convention. With a mob poised to storm the building, he ordered Captain Murat to bring him cannons, which he did, racing the guns through the city streets, allowing Napoleon to mow down the mob with a famous ‘whiff of grapeshot’. Napoleon was hailed as the savior of the government and rewarded with command of the Army of Italy. Murat was promoted Colonel and went with him as his new aide-de-camp.
He soon made a name for himself as a bold and brilliant leader of cavalry, while his height, curly locks, and love of women ensured fame as France’s foremost cavalry commander. In 1798, Murat joined Napoleon’s expedition to Egypt. At the Battle of Aboukir, his flanking charge broke the enemy, and Murat personally took the Ottoman commander prisoner, despite being shot in the jaw – a wound which, to his immense relief, did not ruin his looks. Back in Paris, Napoleon launched his coup d’état to seize political power. When he got a hostile reception from the Council of Five Hundred, it was Murat who saved the day, leading troops in to clear the chamber, shouting ‘Citizens, you have been dissolved’ before adding something more colorful. His place at the future Emperor’s side was further assured when he married Napoleon’s youngest sister Caroline in 1800.
Later that year he commanded the French cavalry reserve at Marengo and helped Napoleon to win a decisive victory over the Austrians. When Napoleon established his empire in 1804, Murat became a Marshal, second in seniority only to Berthier. He’d later also receive the title Prince of the Empire and rank of Grand Admiral. In the 1805 campaign, he commanded Napoleon’s Cavalry Reserve – his excellent reconnaissance and diversions proving crucial in the encirclement of General Mack’s Austrian army at Ulm. Three weeks later, Murat and Marshal Lannes, who normally couldn’t stand each other, together bluffed an Austrian commander into surrendering a vital bridge by persuading him that an armistice had been signed when it hadn’t. It was a bold stunt, but overall, Napoleon was not impressed by Murat’s pursuit of the enemy: “I cannot approve your manner of march. You go on like a stunned fool taking not the least notice of my orders.” Yet in battle, Murat remained a brilliant and inspiring leader, as demonstrated at Austerlitz, and the next year at Jena, where he led the decisive charge wielding only his riding crop.
The next year at Eylau, with the Russians poised to break through his center, Napoleon ordered Murat to lead a mass cavalry charge straight at the enemy. Murat’s men succeeded and saved the army from disaster – though at a terrible price in men and horses. Napoleon had rewarded Murat in 1806 by making him sovereign prince of the Grand Duchy of Berg. In 1808, he sent Murat to Spain to act as his representative. Spain was still a French ally, but in May, Napoleon’s heavy-handed meddling in Spanish affairs triggered a fierce backlash. Madrid rose up against the French garrison, and Murat’s troops fought back with brutal force.
When Napoleon deposed Spain’s Bourbon monarchy, Murat hoped he’d be made the new King of Spain, but that title went to Napoleon’s brother Joseph; Murat,
Napoleon – A French military leader and emperor who rose to prominence during the French Revolution and led several successful campaigns during the Napoleonic Wars. – Napoleon’s strategic genius was evident in his ability to outmaneuver larger armies during his campaigns across Europe.
Marshals – High-ranking officers in the military, often responsible for commanding large units or armies, particularly in the context of the Napoleonic Wars. – The marshals of Napoleon’s army played crucial roles in executing his complex battle plans.
Military – Relating to the armed forces or to soldiers, arms, or war. – The military strategies employed during World War II have been studied extensively by historians and tacticians alike.
Revolution – A fundamental and relatively sudden change in political power and political organization, often accompanied by social upheaval, such as the French Revolution. – The revolution of 1789 dramatically altered the course of French history and inspired movements across the globe.
Victory – The success in a military engagement or war, often resulting in the achievement of strategic objectives. – The victory at the Battle of Austerlitz is considered one of Napoleon’s greatest military achievements.
Campaign – A series of military operations intended to achieve a particular objective, confined to a particular area, or involving a specified type of fighting. – The Italian Campaign showcased Napoleon’s ability to conduct rapid and decisive operations.
France – A country in Western Europe with a rich history of military and cultural influence, particularly noted for its role in the Napoleonic Wars. – France’s involvement in the Napoleonic Wars reshaped the political landscape of Europe in the early 19th century.
Battle – A sustained fight between large organized armed forces, often forming part of a war. – The Battle of Waterloo marked the end of Napoleon’s rule and his final defeat.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs, often focusing on significant developments and their impacts. – The history of the Roman Empire provides valuable insights into the rise and fall of great civilizations.
Leadership – The action of leading a group of people or an organization, often evaluated in terms of effectiveness and impact, especially in military contexts. – The leadership qualities of General Eisenhower were pivotal in coordinating the Allied forces during D-Day.
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional | 11 months | The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". |
viewed_cookie_policy | 11 months | The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data. |